How to File a Claim

Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co.

All Lines except work comp

Call (Toll Free): Hours 8am to 4pm EST 888-717-8090

After Hours 888-530-7741

Workers’ Compensation

After Hours 888-476-2669

1st Choice Advantage Insurance Company Inc.

All Lines

Call (Toll Free): Hours 8am to 4pm EST 888-717-8090

After Hours 888-530-7741

American Reliable Insurance Company

Farm & Agribusiness & Commercial Farm Auto

Call (Toll Free): Hours 8am to 4pm EST 888-717-8090

After Hours 888-530-7741

claims.first.notice@americanreliable.com

Equine Mortality or Medical

Call: (Toll Free): Hours 8am to 4pm EST 888-717-8090

After Hours: Hay’s Adjusting Services, LLC 859-788-5006

claims.first.notice@americanreliable.com