Contact Us

Everett Cash Mutual Insurance Co.

Statutory Home Office

10591 Lincoln Hwy
Everett, PA 15537

1-800-ECM-4YOU

Claims Department

10591 Lincoln Hwy
Everett, PA 15537

1-888-717-8090 (8am-4pm EST)
1-888-530-7741 (after hours)
1-888-476-2669 (Workers Comp Claims)

1st Choice Advantage Insurance Company, Inc.

Statutory Home Office

10591 Lincoln Hwy
Everett, PA 15537

1-800-ECM-4YOU

Claims Department

10591 Lincoln Hwy
Everett, PA 15537

1-888-717-8090 (8am-4pm EST)
1-888-530-7741 (after hours)
1-888-476-2669 (Workers Comp Claims)

American Reliable Insurance Company

Statutory Home Office

3800 N. Central Avenue, Suite 460
Phoenix, AZ 85012

1-800-326-4968

Claims Department

10591 Lincoln Hwy
Everett, PA 15537

1-888-717-8090 (8am-4pm EST)
1-888-530-7741

claims.first.notice@americanreliable.com

Equine Mortality Claims

1-888-717-8090 (8am-4pm EST)
1-888-530-7741  (after hours – Hay’s Adjusting Services, LLC)

claims.first.notice@americanreliable.com

Send us a Email




*Note: This form is for general information questions. If you are an insured requesting a change, please contact your agent. Agents, please contact your Production Underwriter.